Last Week In Science-Based Medicine
- Details
- Written by Dr. Harriet Hall
- Category: Swift
- Hits: 7988
Here is a recap of the stories that appeared last week at Science-Based Medicine, a multi-author skeptical blog that separates the science from the woo-woo in medicine.
It’s a part of my paleo fantasy, it’s a part of my paleo dream (David Gorski) http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/its-a-part-of-my-paleo-fantasy-its-a-part-of-my-paleo-dream/ It is a popular myth that our ancestors were healthy and that diseases like cardiovascular disease are a result of modern lifestyles and can be prevented by diet. A study of ancient mummies spanning 4000 years and 4 different geographic locations shows that atherosclerosis was prevalent in preindustrial populations. The evolutionary arguments for the paleo diet do not stand up to scrutiny.
Dr. Amen’s Love Affair with SPECT Scans (Harriet Hall) http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/dr-amens-love-affair-with-spect-scans/ Dr. Daniel Amen is a psychiatrist (unfortunately featured on PBS) whose chain of Amen Clinics does SPECT scans on all patients, exposing them to radiation and charging them thousands of dollars for a test that has not been shown to contribute to diagnosis or improve treatment of the conditions he treats. An article he wrote to justify his approach is far from convincing.
On Houdini's Birthday: The Skeptical Legacy of Harry Houdini
- Details
- Written by D.J. Grothe
- Category: Swift
- Hits: 9178
A couple days ago, JREF Senior Fellow Jamy Ian Swiss appeared on the talk show HuffPost Live to discuss the skeptical legacy of Harry Houdini, in honor of his 139th birthday. Other guests on the show, hosted by Josh Zepps, included Albert Cadabra from Ripley's Believe It Or Not! Times Square; Buck Wolf, Executive Editor of HuffPost Weird News; and Dorothy Dietrich, director of the Houdini Museum in Scranton, PA.
Watch the episode below.
D.J. Grothe is the President of the James Randi Educational Foundation
The Song Remains the Same
- Details
- Written by Jamy Ian Swiss
- Category: Swift
- Hits: 16715
New York City, 1994, and I answered the ringing telephone. “I’m a producer,” announced the caller, “at WNBC Live-at-Five
on Channel Four, and we’re having a psychic spoon-bender on today. Would you be willing to come in and bend spoons on the air?”
Just another day in the life of a skeptical magician. The psychic spoon-bender had come to the United States from Israel (no, not that psychic spoon-bender) in March of 1994 to try to garner support and belief in several American scientific and academic institutions. The psychic claimant’s name was Ronnie Marcus – a South African native who allegedly practiced faith healing and other psychic skullduggery in Jerusalem. I seem to recall he had a credulous physicist in tow, who apparently believed in Marcus’s supernormal abilities and had helped pave the way to arrange meetings and tests, including in Berkeley, Santa Cruz, Nevada, and elsewhere. (From spiritualism to psychokinesis, physicists often find themselves on the front lines of believing and promoting goofy stuff. [Paging Sir William Crookes!] There are reasons for this, but that is, as they say, another story.)
But upon arriving at American shores, an interesting phenomenon had promptly unfolded. Unlike in the 1970s, when Uri Geller’s psychic tableware modifications were big news, in 1994 we had something new: email. Magicians and skeptics were able to track and swiftly respond to Marcus’s travels and claims, and it became difficult for scientists and parapsychologists to ignore the clamor of such observers offering to take part as informed observers and protocol designers. Thus, for example, even though physicists at Berkeley declined to use protocols suggested by veteran parapsychology expert Ray Hyman, nevertheless, other procedures still managed to thwart Marcus’s attempted magic tricks.
As a result of these swift and decisive failures, Marcus cancelled his remaining appearances and elected to beat a hasty retreat. However since he was flying through New York City on his way out of the country, he had managed to obtain one more television booking on the way out of town and collective memory.
However, a skeptical producer at the station (which was a local NBC affiliate), on learning of Marcus’s planned appearance later that day, put a phone call in to his friend, the late Charles Reynolds, a highly regarded magician, illusion designer, and magic historian. Charles was a lifelong friend of James Randi’s and a friend of mine as well, and he passed my name along to the producer.
Crispian Jago Strikes Again - The Venn Diagram of Irrational Nonsense
- Details
- Written by D.J. Grothe
- Category: Swift
- Hits: 33315
Crispian Jago, the UK-based skeptical blogger at The Reason Stick and co-founder of the Hampshire Skeptics Society and Winchester Skeptics in the Pub, has just published a fantastic Venn Diagram of Irrational Nonsense. Yes, he says it is a "gross over simplification," but I have to love how the perfect intersection of religion, medical quackery, the paranormal and of pseudoscience appears to be nothing other than Scientiology.
Be sure to check out Jago's other projects, like the Skeptic Trumps cards (a few years ago, he did one for Randi and one for me, among many other folks), and fun resources like his Modern Science Map, his Handy Alternative Therapy Flowchart and his Periodic Table of Irrational Nonsense. The man sure knows how to communicate important information with smart graphic design.
D.J. Grothe is president of the James Randi Educational Foundation.
Guide to Skepticism - A Community Document
- Details
- Written by Sharon Hill
- Category: Swift
- Hits: 12033
As the editor and creator of Doubtful News, the critical thinking newsblog, I'm pleased to announce the completion of the Media Guide to Skepticism.
This original document was created for the purpose of providing a clear, easy-to-read guide about the “Skeptical” viewpoint as subscribed to by many who might call themselves Skeptics or critical thinkers. While it was mainly geared towards the media who are interested in providing a "skeptical" viewpoint to their stories, the goal was to explain the difference between practical Skepticism and those that say, “I’m skeptical.” It also clarifies the confusion about "skeptics" versus "denialists" and "truthers" as well as other misconceptions. It turned out to be a good, overall, explanatory piece that even the paranormal crowd appreciated.
Page 65 of 408